The efficacy of arterial only microsurgical nasal replantation: a systematic review
Secanho MS, Rajaram R, de Menezes Neto BF, Cavale N, Ng SK, Neto AAP (2024) · ANZ Journal of Surgery · n=29
Study Profile
- Design
- systematic review of 27 published reports (29 patients) of microsurgical nasal replantation following traumatic amputation, with comparative analysis of arterial-only versus arterial-and-venous anastomosis approaches; Medline, Scopus, and Embase searches through November 2023; JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist for risk-of-bias assessment (Sao Paulo State University, Botucatu Medical School, Brazil; Austin Health, Heidelberg, Victoria, Australia; King's College Hospital and Guy's and St. Thomas Hospital, London, UK)
- Pooled sample (n; included studies may overlap)
- 29
- Scope
- Pooled descriptive analysis of nasal replantation outcomes by anastomosis technique: arterial-only versus arterial-and-venous; medicinal leech therapy use, heparin use, complications, tissue preservation, hospital stay, and follow-up outcomes compared between groups
- Main result
- Arterial-only anastomosis was on average 2 hours 32 minutes faster than arterial-and-venous anastomosis; arterial-only cases used medicinal leech therapy significantly more frequently (p=0.01) while arterial-and-venous cases used heparin more frequently (p=0.01); complications, tissue preservation, hospital stay, and follow-up outcomes were otherwise similar between groups; authors concluded that arterial-only anastomosis is a safe and viable approach for nasal replantation
- PMID
- 39620608
Key Findings
- First systematic review comparing arterial-only versus arterial-and-venous nasal replantation
- Arterial-only approach significantly more often required medicinal leech therapy (p=0.01) for venous congestion management
- Tissue preservation, hospital stay, and follow-up outcomes were comparable between approaches
- Arterial-only approach was 2.5 hours faster on average — practical advantage in emergency reconstruction
- Strengthens the broader literature on arterial-only microsurgical replantation supported by adjunctive leech therapy (ear, finger, nose)
Limitations
- Very small total sample (n=29 patients across 27 studies) - insufficient statistical power for many comparisons
- All included studies were case reports or small series — risk of selection and publication bias high
- Heterogeneous nasal amputation mechanisms (assault, animal bite, motor vehicle accident) - confounding likely
- No randomized comparator design — comparisons rely on pooled descriptive statistics
- Outcome adjudication varied by included study — no centralized review
Clinical Implications
Secanho 2024 is the first systematic review of nasal microsurgical replantation comparing arterial-only and arterial-and-venous approaches. For US clinicians performing emergency nasal replantation under the K040187-cleared microsurgical-salvage indication, the trial establishes that arterial-only replantation supported by medicinal leech therapy is a safe and time-saving alternative when no suitable vein is available for anastomosis. The trial parallels the ear-replant literature (Facchin 2018, Pertea 2021) in demonstrating that leech therapy enables successful single-vessel microsurgical replantation across multiple anatomic sites.
Related studies
Leeching as Salvage Venous Drainage in Ear Reconstruction: Clinical Case and Review of Literature
Facchin F, Lancerotto L, Arnez ZM, Bassetto F, Vindigni V (2018)
Arterial only anastomosis associated with modified Baudet technique in ear replantation: Case reports and literature review
Pertea M, Ciobanu P, Poroch V, Velenciuc N, Lunca S, Anghelina F, Palade DO (2021)
Standardized protocol for artery-only fingertip replantation
Buntic RF, Brooks D (2010)
Total lower lip and chin replantation following a trampoline accident: Rescue surgery with intensive leech therapy
Sounthakith V, Schweitzer-Chaput A, Picard A, Prebot J, Galland A, Neiva-Vaz C, Khonsari RH (2026)